Insight note · 7 November 2026
Steel import estimates: when the CBAM ranking reverses
Anvilmore Research Team

For an EU steel buyer comparing 2026 imports, can a lower gross emissions default establish a smaller Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) cost component? For hot-rolled flat iron or non-alloy steel already classified under CN 7208, the ordering can reverse after the corresponding production-route adjustment. The comparison here concerns default-based estimates for imports where CBAM applies.
Anvilmore's comparison of all 32 named-country entries found 41 strict reversals among 495 pairs with different gross defaults. There were 496 pairs in total, including one gross tie. Every reversal crossed the routes assigned in the default tables; none occurred within a route. These are unweighted comparisons of regulatory inputs, with no claim about their share of steel trade.[2]
Why the deduction changes the order
Free allocation is reflected through a deduction from the gross input: it accounts for the emissions allowances still allocated free to EU producers. Under the default calculation, the deduction depends on the corresponding route benchmark. Different routes can therefore receive different deductions. The binding benchmark rules and Commission guidance establish this mechanism; it is not a uniform percentage reduction in each gross default.[1]
Japan and Thailand show the consequence. The corrected defaults, including the 2026 steel mark-up, put Japan higher on the gross comparison. Applying the respective route adjustments puts Japan lower. All amounts below are tonnes of CO2 equivalent per tonne of goods, before any origin carbon-price credit.[2]
| Origin | Gross 2026 default | After free-allocation adjustment |
|---|---|---|
| Japan | 2.3100 | 0.974250 |
| Thailand | 2.1120 | 2.041800 |
The deduction changes the direction of this comparison, rather than merely narrowing the gap. Within a common assigned route, the same deduction preserves the gross ordering. The finding therefore identifies a boundary for using gross defaults to compare this component; it does not suggest that every comparison reverses.
What a lower carbon line can support
For procurement and finance, the consequence is a different standard of comparison. A lower gross default alone cannot substantiate a lower adjusted carbon line across routes. Compare the amounts after their corresponding adjustments on a consistent basis. With the same import quarter and a common positive certificate price, their ordering also carries into the default-based cost component before origin credits.
These defaults are regulatory inputs, not measured plant or supplier emissions. The assigned routes likewise do not describe every producer in each country. The result cannot rank actual supplier footprints or landed costs, or select the cheaper purchase. Origin credits, actual emissions and the other terms of an offer remain outside it. The judgement this evidence supports is narrower and useful: which adjusted default-based carbon line is lower under the stated comparison conditions.
Sources
As of 7 November 2026; current inputs require rechecking before publication.
[1] Regulation (EU) 2025/2620, Annex 4, equation 6; Annex 5.1 and 5.3, CN 7208 entries. Commission Guidance No. 4, p. 13, Table 2-1 and footnote 10; pp. 17–20, default calculation and corresponding-route instructions. Decision (EU) 2026/1862, Article 1.
[2] Anvilmore calculations using correcting Regulation (EU) 2026/1740, Article 2 and Annex I opening instructions, route legend and CN 7208 country entries, together with the benchmarks and factors in [1].