Insight note · 13 November 2026

When earlier steel imports belong in the next order’s cost

Anvilmore Research Team

Generated overhead illustration of two banded stacks of flat steel sheets on timber supports inside a materials-receiving bay.

For an EU steel buyer comparing an optional import with a feasible EU purchase, how much of the year’s carbon certificate cost belongs to that choice? Under the EU’s Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM), earlier imports can become part of the additional cost, even though those goods have already been bought.

The condition is decisive: the EU purchase must preserve the importer’s mass exemption for the whole calendar year. If another unavoidable import would cross the threshold anyway, the certificate component associated with the earlier goods arises under both alternatives and drops out of this order’s incremental cost.

One choice can change the treatment of earlier goods

The EU’s amended CBAM regulation, Article 2a and Annex VII, exempts an importer whose aggregate covered imports do not exceed 50 tonnes in a calendar year. Exactly 50 tonnes remains within the exemption. Exceeding the threshold brings all that year’s covered embedded emissions into scope. This mass exemption excludes electricity and hydrogen; it is not an allowance for every industrial import.

Consider a hypothetical importer with 49 tonnes of Indian hot-rolled flat steel already imported and an optional two-tonne requirement. Assume the same steel code, CN 72083800, throughout; all imports enter in Q3 2026; there are no other imports, origin-carbon-price credits or other exemptions. A technically and commercially feasible EU purchase meets the additional requirement without adding to the importer’s covered tonnage.

Using published 2026 default inputs and the Commission’s Q3 certificate price, the model certificate component is €277.60 per tonne after the free-allocation adjustment. These are default values, not a producer’s measured emissions.

Choice for the additional requirement Annual covered imports Model certificate component
Feasible EU purchase 49 tonnes €0: mass exemption retained
Additional Indian import 51 tonnes €14,158

Of the €14,158 difference, approximately €555 relates to the additional two tonnes and €13,603 to the earlier 49 tonnes. The earlier purchase expenditure is already committed; the certificate component associated with it becomes avoidable through this choice only because the EU alternative preserves the annual exemption.

The alternative determines the allowance

Under these assumptions, this component alone could justify up to €14,158 of additional EU purchase cost. That does not establish that the EU offer wins: its price, freight, ordinary duties, qualification and compliance costs remain outside this comparison. Actual verified emissions or an eligible origin-carbon-price reduction could also change the amount.

This is a historical Q3 illustration assessed as of 13 November 2026, not an actual shipment assessment or a current Q4 quote. The Commission’s price table gives €82.32 per tonne of CO₂ equivalent for Q3; Q4 is not yet published.

The purchasing judgement is therefore which exposure the optional order causes. If later unavoidable imports remove the exemption under both choices, the earlier 49-tonne component can no longer support a premium for choosing the EU offer.

Sources and model parameters

The model uses the corrected India CN 7208 default of 4.280 tonnes CO₂ equivalent per tonne, with the 2026 10% markup. The CN 72083800 route-C benchmark is 1.370, with a 2026 CBAM factor of 0.975 and cross-sectoral correction factor of 1.00. Rounded totals use unrounded inputs.